在座的各位都是AA法案的受益者,为什么反对AA呢?

我记得川普任上也有个tax cut act

:troll: 怪零靠SAT上Stanford就跟某人靠选票当一把手的因果关系一样强

3 个赞

哥们儿,小心Misaka不让你回去 :troll:

:yaoming:我在泥潭一般都很文明,但是这次我想说楼主烧饼。简单粗暴一点好吧,估计白金不保了

:yaoming:
怪零妈妈也是的,回北京就玩玩就好了还去补课 :rofl:

3 个赞

其他都是小菜,Self identify age才是神之一手

1 个赞

前段时间才抓了一个女的,三十多还是四五十岁了,假装高中生去读书 :troll: 说是怀念那段最美好的时光,哈哈

1 个赞

我学校自从猛招国际生排名年年前进,因为国际生给的太多了突然有钱了可以买人才买设备了
反对不是因为自己没受益才反对的么,如果Asian也能降分录取,甚至起码承认和black Latino有同等权利,爬藤的家长应该支持起来比谁都欢

1 个赞

自称10岁8岁的话大多数地方门票都不用给了。自称2岁的话迪斯尼环球影城门票也免了

这贴在首页飘着真难受,谁来夸几句AA吧,感谢渣IT送的会员 :rofl:

反对 AA 因为 Barclay AA 8/24 拒了我 :crazy_face:

GPA 8/24?

3 个赞

不是泥潭政治观点就这么surface level吗,MLK是race blind是多少年前就debunk的?

Dr. King’s line about not judging his children “by the color of their skin but by the content of their character” is too often shamefully applied to argue against affirmative action or any race-based remedy to historical injustice. But the “I Have a Dream” speech itself contradicts this in his bold call for fighting the fight “until justice rolls down like waters and righteousness like a mighty stream.” Moreover, his public views before and after this speech included support of the Indian government’s special employment opportunities provided to the caste formally referred to as untouchables as a remedy for these discrimination victims, social reforms for African Americans similar to the G.I. Bill, and a call for “massive” reparations that were bold, but “less expensive than any computation based on two centuries of unpaid wages and accumulated interest." In essence, Dr. King’s argument is not to be color blind


自己观点是啥无所谓我也无所谓,咱别misquote 了,you can’t appeal to the ethos if it’s literally contrary to the whole idea

6 个赞

所以到底怎么从这句话看出来MLK反对race blind的?原文附近不都是在反对黑人遭到不平等对待吗?

There are those who are asking the devotees of civil rights, when will you be satisfied? We can never be satisfied as long as the Negro is the victim of the unspeakable horrors of police brutality. We can never be satisfied as long as our bodies, heavy with the fatigue of travel, cannot gain lodging in the motels of the highways and the hotels of the cities.

We cannot be satisfied as long as the Negro’s basic mobility is from a smaller ghetto to a larger one. We can never be satisfied as long as our children are stripped of their selfhood and robbed of their dignity by signs stating: for whites only.

We cannot be satisfied as long as a Negro in Mississippi cannot vote and a Negro in New York believes he has nothing for which to vote.

No, no, we are not satisfied, and we will not be satisfied until justice rolls down like waters, and righteousness like a mighty stream.

Proponents of Proposition 209 have suggested Martin Luther King Jr. would support their attempt to derail affirmative action. They went so far as to prepare a television commercial containing a clip from King’s famous “I Have a Dream” speech. The King estate protested, the spot was pulled–but not before successfully creating some confusion.

Fortunately, California need not rely on Ward Connerly to interpret for King. The civil rights leader left a record of his views: a body of speeches, interviews, books and sermons, many of which have been published in an anthology, “A Testament of Hope.”

Flip through it and one finds that, among other things, King said, “Whenever the issue of compensatory treatment for the Negro is raised, some of our friends recoil in horror. The Negro should be granted equality, they agree; but he should ask nothing more. On the surface, this appears reasonable, but it is not realistic.”

He said, “A society that has done something special against the Negro for hundreds of years must now do something special for the Negro.”

He said, “A section of the white population, perceiving Negro pressure for change, misconstrues it as a demand for privileges rather than as a desperate quest for existence. The ensuing white backlash intimidates government officials who are already too timorous.”


Is this not a word for word endorsement of AA?

5 个赞

多了去了,还可以self identified sat score, competition champions, enrollment suitability :yaoming:

感谢,我认真读了下。很有价值的文章。

如果让我粗浅地总结一下的话,那就是dream和reality是有区别的。MLK的那几句话未必代表他本人对affirmative action的立场。

3 个赞

灵活的种族歧视定义 :yaoming: 以前看根据种族调整是种族歧视,现在不看种族是种族歧视。
好奇20年后得什么样。

(实在不理解merit-based居然能是歧视,真想帮助弱势群体按照家庭资产和收入去调整要比种族合理多了吧)

MLK本来就有很complicated和完善的的政治思想和诉求

简化的太离谱了

5 个赞

你怎么敢定义他的年龄,“心理年龄和生理年龄不一样的!!”“我们这个时代需要更多包容!” “说得好!你有权利选择自己的年龄!”